Geno Smith Joins the Raiders: A Strategic Move for Pete Carroll’s Vision

In a bold move, new Las Vegas Raiders head coach Pete Carroll aims to make an immediate impact rather than enter a rebuilding phase. The Raiders have acquired veteran quarterback Geno Smith from the Seattle Seahawks for a 2025 third-round pick, marking a significant reunion for the coach and player.

The Smith-Carroll Connection

During his tenure with Carroll, Smith earned recognition as a two-time Pro Bowl quarterback, accumulating 8,641 passing yards, 55 touchdowns, and 21 interceptions over 37 games. This experience under Carroll’s guidance is expected to translate into an effective partnership as the Raiders prepare for the 2025 season.

The Raiders’ Quarterback Search

The Raiders had been actively exploring potential quarterbacks to enhance their competitiveness. Their attempt to acquire Matthew Stafford from the Los Angeles Rams was unsuccessful, leading them to focus on Smith. The organization believes that landing Smith addresses a crucial void in their roster and aligns with their ambition to improve.

Financial Implications for Seattle

The Seahawks will benefit financially from this trade, saving $31 million in cash and cap space, although they incur $13.5 million in dead money. This move gives Seattle the flexibility to find a long-term solution at quarterback, as concerns linger about Smith’s future with the team, particularly in consideration of his age and inconsistent performance.

Assessing Seattle’s Future

While the Seahawks are not entering a full rebuild, they must address significant gaps in their roster, particularly at the quarterback position and potentially at wide receiver, depending on the situation with DK Metcalf’s trade request. The team is positioned to explore options in the free agent market, potentially including candidates like Sam Darnold or even a surprising move for a player such as Aaron Rodgers.

Impact on the Raiders’ Offense

Under new offensive coordinator Chip Kelly, the Raiders are aiming to rectify their offensive struggles that saw them ranked 29th in points per game in 2024. Smith’s proven ability to pass for over 4,000 yards in two of the past three seasons makes him a valuable asset. Coupled with tight end Brock Bowers, who shone despite inconsistent quarterback play, Smith’s presence is expected to bolster the team’s scoring capabilities.

Remaining Challenges for the Raiders

While acquiring Smith addresses the quarterback situation, the Raiders still have pressing needs to address if they wish to compete in the tough AFC West. Their rushing attack was notably underwhelming, finishing last in rushing yards per game in 2024. The upcoming draft presents an opportunity to select a running back like Ashton Jeanty from Boise State to improve this aspect of their game.

Seattle’s Trade Considerations

Metcalf’s future with the Seahawks remains uncertain after Smith’s departure. While his trade request was previously noted, it remains to be seen whether his views will change with a new quarterback dynamic. General manager John Schneider has emphasized making financially savvy decisions, which could involve trading Metcalf if the right offer surfaces.

Quarterback Options for the Seahawks

The Seahawks’ options in the quarterback market are varied and could lead to an intriguing offseason. Candidates include Kirk Cousins from the Atlanta Falcons, who has familiarity with Seattle’s offensive system, and Darnold, who is seen as a solid bridge quarterback. The team may also explore drafting a quarterback in the middle rounds as a backup plan.

Draft Strategies for Both Teams

The Raiders’ trade for Smith removes them from the early quarterback conversation in the draft. Instead, with the sixth overall pick, they can now pursue the best talent available, whether it be Jeanty, defensive end Shemar Stewart from Texas A&M, or even an offensive lineman like Will Campbell from LSU.

Conversely, the Seahawks, picking at 18, may need to reassess their quarterback strategy. While a quarterback might not be their primary focus, bolstering their offensive line by selecting a player like Armand Membou from Missouri could prove beneficial for future stability.

A Path Forward for Both Organizations

The trade represents a significant turning point for both the Raiders and Seahawks. With Smith back under Carroll’s guidance in Las Vegas, expectations are high for immediate improvement. Meanwhile, Seattle must navigate the potential transitions ahead while maintaining a competitive edge in the league.